Features

Integrations

Pricing

Docs

Get Started

All posts

Gateway outage yesterday? Recover failed subscription payments now

Guides

min read

Gateway outage yesterday? Recover failed subscription payments now

Payment gateway outages can cause subscription businesses to lose up to 15% of monthly revenue through failed transactions and involuntary churn. Quick action within 24 hours—identifying failed payments, activating smart retries that recover 70% of transactions, and transparent customer communication—determines recovery success. Multi-gateway redundancy prevents future single-point failures.

At a Glance

• Gateway outages affect even major providers like Square, which experienced a system-wide disruption on February 26 due to certificate validation issues

• Failed payments drive involuntary churn that can account for up to 40% of total churn in subscription businesses

• Smart retry systems using machine learning can recover 70% of failed transactions when implemented quickly

• Multi-gateway orchestration eliminates single points of failure by automatically routing transactions to backup providers during outages

• Acquiring new customers costs 5 to 25 times more than retention, making payment recovery critical for unit economics

Yesterday's payment gateway disruption left thousands of subscription businesses scrambling. If you woke up to a dashboard full of failed transactions, you're not alone. The good news? Most of that revenue is recoverable, but only if you act quickly and strategically.

This guide walks you through exactly what happened, how much it's costing you, and the step-by-step actions you need to take in the next 24 hours to win back customers and protect your recurring revenue.

What happened in yesterday's gateway outage—and why does single-gateway dependency hurt?

Payment gateway outages aren't rare anomalies. "At one time or another, most payment gateways experience outages and performance issues," according to Recurly's analysis. Even industry giants face these challenges.

Take the recent Square incident as an example. "On February 26, we experienced a system-wide service disruption affecting Square payment processing and Cash App services," Square reported in their official post-mortem. The root cause? A security certificate validation problem that temporarily prevented payment systems from communicating with databases. "Functionality began to recover at 20:58 and fully recovered at 21:03," they noted, but even that brief window caused significant disruption.

The problem with relying on a single gateway becomes painfully clear during these events. When your payment gateway experiences an outage, it creates multiple negative implications:

Existing subscribers can't renew
New customers can't sign up
Revenue collection grinds to a halt

"If a new subscriber is attempting to sign up for a subscription, they won't be able to—and they may never return to try their purchase again," warns Recurly.

This single-point-of-failure architecture means your entire payment infrastructure is only as reliable as your weakest link. When that link breaks, everything downstream fails.

How much revenue do outages and failed payments really cost?

The financial impact of gateway outages extends far beyond the immediate downtime window. Failed payments don't just mean delayed revenue. "A churn rate of 5% per month is equal to losing nearly half of your existing customers in a single year—meaning half of your revenue," according to Recurly's churn benchmarks report.

The math is stark:

Metric	Impact
Monthly revenue going uncollected	15% on average
Potential subscriber loss from involuntary churn	7.2% monthly
Involuntary churn as share of total churn	Up to 40%

"Acquiring a new customer is anywhere from 5 to 25 times more expensive than retaining an existing one," notes Recurly's research. Every subscriber lost to a payment failure represents not just lost revenue, but wasted acquisition spend.

The scale of the problem is substantial. Analysis of over $3 billion in subscription revenue revealed that involuntary churn, primarily from failed payments, can easily comprise 40% or more of total churn.

For high-volume subscription businesses, Slicker's AI-powered recovery engine helps capture this revenue that would otherwise be lost. By layering on top of your existing billing system, Slicker uses smart retries to recover 70% of failed transactions through machine-learning that identifies the optimal retry timing for each payment.

Key takeaway: The cost of a gateway outage isn't just the transactions that failed during downtime. It's the cascade of involuntary churn, lost new signups, and customer trust erosion that follows.

First-day playbook: triage failed payments & win back customers

Time is critical. Here's your action plan for the first 24 hours.

Step 1: Identify what failed

First, determine the scope of the damage. Stripe's webhook documentation explains that subscription management happens asynchronously, so you'll need to actively pull failed transaction data.

Look for:

Invoices with requires_payment_method status
Webhook events showing invoice.payment_failed
Communication errors in your gateway logs

Recurly's intelligent retry system handles different error types with specific retry schedules:

Try Again/Gateway Error: Retry every 2 days
Issuer or Processor Unavailable: Retry every 3 days
Communication/Configuration Error: Initial retries up to 2 times, 4 hours apart

Step 2: Activate smart retries

Don't retry everything at once. Machine-learning powered retry systems can recover 70% of failed transactions by identifying the optimal retry timing for each transaction.

Your billing platform likely offers automated retry features. If you're using Stripe, their Smart Retries feature analyzes patterns across billions of transactions. The key is scheduling retries at staggered intervals, not flooding the gateway immediately after it recovers.

For businesses on Chargebee or Zuora, Slicker integrates directly with your existing payment rails to add an AI-powered retry layer. Our system analyzes transaction patterns to determine the best retry windows, helping you recover more revenue without changing your core infrastructure.

Step 3: Consider offline or backup processing

During network degradation, consider collecting card payments offline as a temporary measure. This keeps transactions flowing while you work on recovery.

Notify & reassure customers quickly

Transparent communication preserves customer relationships. Catchpoint's analysis of major payment outages emphasizes the importance to communicate transparently during incidents.

Your customer communication should:

Acknowledge the issue proactively
Explain that their subscription remains active
Provide a self-service link to update payment details
Set clear expectations for when they'll be charged

Set up notifications through your gateway's status page. Stripe, for example, allows you to receive email notifications whenever they create, update, or resolve an incident.

Key takeaway: The first 24 hours after an outage determine how much revenue you'll ultimately recover. Fast identification, smart retries, and proactive communication are your highest-leverage actions.

Is multi-gateway routing the cure for single-point failure?

Yesterday's outage exposed a fundamental architectural weakness. Here's how to fix it permanently.

"Payments orchestration refers to the intelligent management of multiple payment service providers (PSPs), gateways, fraud tools, and alternative payment methods (APMs) through a unified platform or layer," explains Paymentspedia's comprehensive guide.

Think of it as a control tower for payments. The core capabilities include:

Smart Routing: Dynamically routes transactions to the best-performing PSP
PSP Redundancy: Ensures business continuity if one PSP fails
Tokenization: Centralized vaulting of customer card data across providers
Unified Reporting: Single dashboard for all payment metrics

Recurly's Gateway Failover feature illustrates this in practice. It automatically routes transactions to a backup gateway whenever there's a detected outage with the primary gateway, then reverts back after resolution.

"Using Gateway Failover technology, Recurly automatically activated our backup gateway, allowing us to continue to process subscribers' transactions," said Ryan MacGregor, Managing Director at Macabacus, in a testimonial.

The solution is straightforward: multiple payment gateways. When one connection experiences downtime, transactions can automatically reroute to another provider without disruption.

Beyond redundancy, multi-gateway routing offers:

Higher authorization rates through optimal routing
Lower transaction costs by choosing the cheapest available path
Geographic optimization for international transactions

Choosing an orchestration layer vs. building in-house

"The most critical decision for merchants is whether to invest in a proprietary solution or use a third party," notes The Paypers' analysis of payment orchestration.

Here's how the options compare:

Factor	Third-Party Orchestration	In-House Build
Time to implement	Weeks	Months to years
Maintenance burden	Vendor-managed	Your engineering team
PSP integrations	Pre-built (100+)	Build each one
Cost structure	Per-transaction fees	Fixed engineering costs
Customization	Limited to platform features	Unlimited

"The payment orchestration platform market size is set to be worth over $3.7 billion a year by 2028, growing at a compound annual rate of 22.4%," according to Spreedly's orchestration guide. This growth reflects the industry's recognition that orchestration isn't optional for serious subscription businesses.

Leading orchestration providers include Spreedly, known for gateway-agnostic orchestration with deep PSP integrations, and Primer, which offers a UX-focused modular platform with no-code tools.

"It was something super good for us to find [Spreedly] and we implemented Spreedly as this orchestration system that will allow us to create these connections to these different payment gateways and processors. And by now our acceptance rates increased and we are just rejecting between 5% to 8% of the transactions," shared a Zebrands representative in Spreedly's case study.

Monitoring, SLAs & chaos testing: proving your stack can survive the next outage

Prevention beats recovery. Here's how to build resilience before the next outage hits.

Catchpoint's post-mortem of a major 2025 payments outage revealed that the issue was detected through synthetic monitoring that flagged malformed HTTP/2 responses. This customer-perspective monitoring caught the problem before internal systems did.

Your monitoring should track:

API response times and error rates
Gateway status page feeds
Webhook delivery success rates
End-to-end transaction completion

Most gateway providers commit to specific uptime guarantees. "AWS will use commercially reasonable efforts to make API Gateway available with a Monthly Uptime Percentage of at least 99.95% for each AWS region," states the AWS API Gateway SLA.

Typical SLA commitments include:

99.9% availability over 24-hour periods
Response time limits (often 5-7 seconds)
Service credits for missed targets

But here's the catch: SLAs won't prevent outages, and service credits won't recover your lost customers. "Service Credits will not entitle you to any refund or other payment from AWS," notes the AWS SLA. The credits only apply to future bills.

Catchpoint recommends businesses design for failure and build for bypass. This means:

Chaos testing: Deliberately simulate gateway failures to verify your failover works
Runbook documentation: Pre-written procedures for common failure scenarios
Automated alerting: Immediate notification when error rates spike
Regular failover drills: Test your backup gateway monthly, not just when production breaks

Note that some failover features can't be tested in sandbox mode. Recurly's Gateway Failover, for example, is functional only in production mode.

Key takeaway: The organizations that recover fastest from outages are those who practiced for them. Build monitoring, understand your SLAs' limitations, and test your failover before you need it.

Key takeaways & why redundancy should be priority #1

Yesterday's outage was expensive, but it doesn't have to be repeated. Here's what to implement immediately:

Triage now: Identify all failed transactions and queue them for smart retries at staggered intervals
Communicate proactively: Reach out to affected customers before they contact you
Add a backup gateway: Single-gateway dependency is a business risk, not a technical constraint
Implement orchestration: Modern payment orchestration platforms handle failover automatically
Monitor continuously: Catch the next outage before your customers do

The subscription economy continues to grow, with recovery tools reclaiming over $155 million for software companies alone in 2025. But recovery is always harder than prevention.

For high-volume subscription businesses using Chargebee, Zuora, or in-house billing systems, Slicker offers an AI-powered approach to failed payment recovery. Slicker's engine sits on top of your existing billing and payment systems, using smart retries to reduce involuntary churn and increase recovered revenue, all with pay-for-success pricing that aligns with your results.

The best time to build payment redundancy was before yesterday's outage. The second-best time is today.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the consequences of a single-gateway dependency during an outage?

A single-gateway dependency can lead to significant disruptions during an outage, including halted revenue collection, inability for existing subscribers to renew, and potential loss of new customers who may not return to complete their purchase.

How much revenue can be lost due to payment gateway outages?

Payment gateway outages can lead to substantial revenue loss, not only from immediate failed transactions but also from involuntary churn. Involuntary churn can account for up to 40% of total churn, significantly impacting long-term revenue.

What steps should be taken immediately after a payment gateway outage?

After a payment gateway outage, businesses should quickly identify failed transactions, activate smart retries to recover payments, and communicate transparently with customers to maintain trust and minimize churn.

How does Slicker help in recovering failed subscription payments?

Slicker uses an AI-powered recovery engine that integrates with existing billing systems to perform smart retries, recovering up to 70% of failed transactions and reducing involuntary churn.

What is payment orchestration and how does it prevent outages?

Payment orchestration involves managing multiple payment service providers through a unified platform, enabling smart routing and redundancy. This ensures business continuity by automatically rerouting transactions during outages.